Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets: Which Is Better?

Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets: Which Is Better?

Do you own a pellet grill? If so, which brand do you have? There is a lot of debate between Pit Boss pellets and Traeger pellets. Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets, which one is better? Both have their pros and cons, but in the end, it really depends on what you are looking for in a pellet grill.

In this blog post, we will compare Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets, and give some information about the pros and cons of thư two types of pellets so that you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you. So, keep reading to learn more about them.
Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets

What Is Pit Boss Pellet?

Before comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets, it is important to understand what Pit Boss pellets are. Pit Boss offers a large selection of all-natural, all-hardwood smoking pellets. Pit Boss pellets include no artificial flavors, sprays, glues, or chemicals, resulting in a high-quality product that reliably produces the even heat and pure smoke you need for consistently excellent results.

Moreover, Pit Boss pellets are available in a variety of types and flavors, including Apple, Cherry, Hickory, Mesquite, Oak, and many more. With Pit Boss pellets each pellet is hand-inspected to ensure it meets its premium standards before being shipped out to customers.

What Is The Traeger Pellet?

Traeger offers a wide array of cooking and grilling products, and their pellets are one of the best options for providing authentic smoke flavor in food. Traeger is known for producing top-of-the-line durable long-lasting grills, pellet smokers, and accessories. All products made by Traeger are designed to live up to their standards and deliver exceptional quality results every time.

Especially, Traeger wood pellets, like Pit Boss, are composed entirely of natural, food-grade hardwoods. Traeger pellets do not include any fillers, additives, or flavors.

Traeger has more than 20 years of expertise in manufacturing high-quality pellets as the initial maker of pellets and pellet smokers. As a result, they proclaim to have established the gold standard in pellet manufacturing and efficiency.

Some Information About Pit Boss:

One of the earliest firms to compete with Traeger was Pit Boss.

Dan Thiessen created the firm in 1999 as a branch of Dansons, Inc. Alberta is where the firm is based.

To combat Traeger, Pit Boss Grills presented themselves as a more economical pellet grill choice.

The popular Louisiana pellet smokers are made by the same firm. You can see our evaluation of their renowned Black Label Pellet Grill Series here.

Joe Traeger entered Dansons in 2018 to operate on either the Pit Boss or Louisiana grill brands, which was an unusual coincidence.

Some Information About The Trager:

Traeger has the more fascinating history of the two brands.

After testing with burning wood stoves, Joe Traeger came up with the initial concept for Traeger grills.

In 1985, he designed his first pellet grill, which he registered in 1986.

Over the following 20 years, Traeger had a complete stranglehold on the pellet grill industry.

Traeger stayed a small family business headquartered in Oregon throughout this time.

When the patent on the product expired in 2006, a slew of new rivals rushed onto the market.

Since Jeremy Andrus entered Traeger in 2014 and relocated the firm to Salt Lake City, the brand has skyrocketed in popularity.

Traeger is now the world’s largest pellet barbecue producer, manufacturing more than $300 million in total grills each year.

Pit Boss Pellets Are Made In What Country?

Pit Boss is an American brand that distributes its products domestically. Most of the company’s customers are located in America, but some live in Canada as well. Nonetheless, Pit Boss is committed to manufacturing quality products at a competitive cost, ensuring each customer will receive value for their money without skimping on product quality or service.

Where Do Traeger Pellets Come From?

Traeger wood pellets are made in the United States. The company’s headquarters are located in Kansas City, MO. They also have plants located in Georgia and Texas where they produce their pellets.

Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets: The Comparison – Key Differences 

There are some differences between the Pit Boss Pellets And Traeger Pellets:

Taste & Quality

The first thing you should consider when comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets is the taste & quality.

  • Traeger Pellet:

As far as Traeger pellets go, they are manufactured with 100% hardwood for an authentic wood-fire taste; no fillers, additives, or sprays. Unfortunately, some customers didn’t like the off-taste of the resulting flavor and preferred the original Traeger pellets.

  • Pit Boss Pellet:

Pit Boss pellets are made entirely from hardwood sawdust compressed under high heat and pressure to form 100% all-natural premium hardwood pellets that burn reliably at high temps without producing any off-tastes or flavors. Moreover, they’re available in a variety of types and flavors to suit your unique tastes. Because of these benefits, Pit Boss has earned more trust than Traeger for many customers.

Construction 

The next thing you should consider when comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets is the construction.

  • Traeger Pellet:

A bag of Traeger pellets is made from compressed hardwood sawdust and other ingredients. When this mixture is pressed under high pressure, the result is all-natural wood pellets that burn reliably at high temps without producing any off-tastes or flavors.

  • Pit Boss Pellet:

All Pit Boss wood pellet grills and smokers use 100% pure hardwood pellets compressed at 300 degrees under extreme heat and pressure to form highly combustible all-natural premium hardwood pellets with no binders, chemicals, fillers, additives, or sprays.

Price

Another thing to consider when comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets is the price.

  • Pit Boss Pellet:

Compared to other brands, Pit Boss is more affordable with 30lbs bags of all-natural compressed hardwood pellets for sale at around $35.

  • Traeger Pellet:

A bag of 18lbs of Traeger all-natural wood pellets sells for about $40-$50.

Direct-Flame Ability 

The direct-flame ability is also one of the things that you should keep in mind when comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets.

  • Traeger Pellet:

Traeger pellets can be burned directly in most pellet grills, but the best way to use them is with Traeger’s optional Smokehouse wood pellet smoker box.

  • Pit Boss Pellet:

You can burn Pit Boss pellets on any high heat source like an open flame or hot charcoal. However, it is recommended that you burn these hardwood pellets using an electric, propane, natural gas, or wood-fired grill or smoker for more even cooking and better results.

Availability

The next thing you should consider when comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets is the availability.

  • Traeger Pellet:

Traeger pellets are available in a large number of flavors and types that vary by region, so you’ll need to check with your local dealer before purchasing one.

  • Pit Boss Pellet:

You can buy Pit Boss pellets from many stores, including Cabela’s, Bass Pro Shops, Walmart, Home Depot, and more. You can also buy it directly from the manufacturer’s online store.

Storage 

The storage is another thing that you should keep in mind when comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets.

  • Traeger Pellet:

Keep your Traeger pellets in a cool, dry place inside the original packaging until you’re ready to use them. Make sure they’re not exposed to direct sunlight or excess moisture. Also, be aware that Traeger pellets have a shelf-life of up to 2 years, so it’s best to use them before that date.

  • Pit Boss Pellet:

Unlike Traeger, Pit Boss pellets don’t require any special storage and can be kept in the original packaging for up to three years.

Warranty

Another thing to consider when comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets is the warranty.

  • Traeger Pellet:

Traeger pellet grills and smokers are designed for outdoor use only. They’re built with stainless steel components that resist rust, heat, weathering, and corrosion; all of which can greatly reduce the lifespan of your grill or smoker.

  • Pit Boss Pellet:

Each Pit Boss pellet grill is backed by a 15-year limited consumer warranty on all parts; a 1-year limited warranty on the electronic control board; 2-years limited warranty on the burn pot.

Cooking Ability

The final thing you should consider when comparing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets is the cooking ability.

  • Traeger Pellet:

Traeger pellets produce more smoke than any other brand because they burn hotter (about 800 degrees Fahrenheit), faster, and at very high pressure inside your Traeger wood pellet box to give you longer burns and more intense flavor. These hotter and higher temperatures produce very little ash, which means you will have less clean-up after each cooking session.

  • Pit Boss Pellet:

Because they burn at a lower temperature (about 500 degrees Fahrenheit), Pit Boss pellets create less smoke than Traeger and don’t require as much time to burn consistently for results that are just as good if not better than Traeger. Each Pit Boss pellet is also made from 100% hardwood sawdust and no fillers or additives, so there’s nothing to clean up afterward except the grease on your plate.

Alright, we have a general look at the comparison, particularly about the key differences in both two types of pellet – Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets.

Pit Boss Pellets: How Are They Made?

Besides, to have a clear comparison between the two types of pellets Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets, we come to the process by which Pit Boss and Traeger pellets are made. So, let’s begin with how Pit Boss pellets are made.

Pit Boss claims that its logs are generally taken from storm-damaged trees or trees towards the end of its lifetime, yet they aren’t touted as completely sustainable. This increases the health of the forest while minimizing the environmental effect.

After the logs are gathered and transported to the Pit Boss Pellet Mill, they are categorized by type and chopped down to limit end ashes output and keep the auger from clogging.

After that, the logs are chopped and combined into the necessary mixtures.

After that, the chips are dried three times to get the water content down to the necessary level for combustion byproducts. They’re then treated in a particular machine after going through a grinding machine to decrease the chip area to sawdust. It involves heating the wood to release the natural tannin in the timber, which serves as a glue to keep the pellets together without the need for glue or additives.

The pellets are wrapped in plastic packaging once they have cooled to retain moisture during shipment and storage at your home.

What Is the Process of Making Traeger Pellets?

The primary process is the same as Pit Boss: first, logs are gathered and transported to the Traeger Mill where they’re categorized by type; chopped, and mixed. Then, they go through a drying process twice to get the moisture level right for combustion byproducts. Next, they go through a grinding machine before going through a heating treatment (like Pit Boss’s tannin release method) which keeps them from falling apart.

Then, pellets rely on an adhesive free-pelleting process that produces uniform pellet size and shape without relying on additives or chemicals. Afterward, pellets go through an additional cooling phase which creates smooth surfaces and round shapes that fuse together nicely and lead to less breakage during shipping and storage at your home.

How Do Pit Boss Pellets Work?

Moreover, understanding the operation of both Pit Boss and Traeger pellets also helps us to have an obvious look at the two pellets – Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets, which is the better choice. 

Pellet smokers and grills offer a lot of advantages compared to traditional and charcoal smokers and grills. They use compressed wood (or other natural products like corn or grape stalks) for fuel to produce heat and smoke, eliminating the need to add wood chips every time you cook. This means that pellet smokers will save money when used properly since any pellets not burned in the smoker can be reused later.

Using pellets is also more efficient than other types of fuel because there’s no need to add additional coals during cooking; just do so before you start your cook if you want to add them halfway through!

Pit Boss pellets are also very easy to transport, making them ideal for using while camping or tailgating and are great for cooking at home on a stove or grill.

How Do Traeger Pellets Work?

Traeger pellets are designed to work in Traeger, HMB, Green Mountain Grills, Davy Crockett, Smokin-it & Memphis pellet grills.

Unlike Pit Boss’s industry-leading pellets which can be used across many brands with little to no modification, Traeger offers its own pellet grill which has a few limitations compared to the others on this list.

For example, the Traeger only uses one size of pellet that it claims is 100% natural hardwood without fillers or binders. While it does boast an impressive 20 lb capacity hopper, there have been reports of issues with uneven feed and poor quality control by some customers.

You’ll need an external temperature control unit for setting up to get the most out of Traeger pellets since their large hopper means you can’t use air to regulate temperature, though some users claim they have found ways to do it.

Lastly, one feature all pellet brands should consider adding is a built-in probe to easily check what’s going on inside the grill without resorting to constantly opening the lid.

What Is The Pit Boss Pellet Quality And Consistency Like?

So, what about the quality and consistency of the two pellets: Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets? To begin with, we come to the Pit Boss pellets.

Pellet Boss has most of the same benefits as Traeger does with its pellets, except that they only come in one type and size. They also boast a 20 lb capacity hopper which can be somewhat limiting if you’re cooking for a large group of people over a long period of time.

Their pellets are produced from 100% natural hardwood with no additives or chemicals and use an adhesive free-pelleting process for a uniform shape without the need for binders or fillers.

What Is The Traeger Pellet Quality And Consistency Like?

Traeger prides itself on offering its own brand of high-quality 100% all-natural pellets that produce impressively consistent results every time as well as having larger more manageable hoppers that can hold up to 20 lbs of pellets for longer cooking.

However, unlike Pit Boss, they only offer one type and size of the pellet which means you’ll have to adjust your recipes accordingly if you want to try something different from what’s recommended in your grill’s manual.

Traeger has also been known to have issues with feeder mechanisms on some units as well as uneven cook times and poor temperature control early in their lifespan which has been reported by a number of customers.

What Traeger Pellet Flavors Are Available?

Traeger offers a variety of flavors including apple, mesquite, cherry, alder, and oak.

Apple: More mild than hickory, with a sweet yet slightly tart taste. Good for poultry and pork.

Hickory: Sweet & Smoky, works well with beef, poultry, or pork.

Maple: Very mild with a subtle sweetness, good for poultry or beef.

Mesquite: Stronger flavor than apple or cherry – great if you like your food on the smoky side! Works well for beef, seafood, and chicken.

Cherry: Less intense than hickory or mesquite due to its subtle flavor profile; best for lighter meats like fish and pork.

Oak: A traditional cooking wood that works great with red meats like steak & hamburgers because it gives them a hearty natural smoky flavor without overpowering them with over-the-top taste.

Alder: Slightly sweet & delicately savory, it works best with seafood or poultry due to its lighter flavor.

What Pit Boss Pellet Flavors Are Available?

In addition, how about the availability of Pit Boss and Traeger pellets. Actually, knowing this information will assist us when choosing Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets. Which one is better?

Pit Boss offers a variety of flavors including mesquite, hickory, apple, cherry, oak, alder, etc.

Mesquite: More intense than Hickory – great for beef or chicken.

Hickory: Sweet & Smoky flavor that works well with pork and beef.

Apple: Milder in taste than the hickory and mesquite and works well with lighter meats like fish and poultry.

Cherry: Less intense than hickory or mesquite due to its subtle flavor profile; best for lighter meats like fish and pork.

Oak: A traditional cooking wood that works great with red meats like steak & hamburgers because it gives them a hearty natural smoky flavor without overpowering them with over-the-top taste.

Alder: Slightly sweet & delicately savory, it works best with seafood or poultry due to its lighter flavor.

Maple: Very mild with a subtle sweetness, good for poultry or beef.

Charcoal: A more natural choice than mesquite or hickory, great for bringing out the flavor of fish and poultry.

Trophy: A blend of hickory & cherry, with delicate flavors that work great for all types of meat.

Pitmaster Blend: A blend of hickory, cherry, alder, and oak that works best for red meats like steak & hamburgers.

Pecan: A milder cooking wood with a nutty flavor profile that works well with poultry and pork.

Pit Boss Pellets: How Much Do They Cost?

So, what about the cost of them. Whether the two pellets (Pit Boss pellets vs Traeger pellets) are too expensive or moderate. We will begin with the Pit Boss pellets.

Pit Boss pellets aren’t the most affordable pellets on the market. They are, however, not the most affordable.

Most Pit Boss pellet flavors are available in two sizes: 20 lbs. and 40 lbs.

The 20 pound Pit Boss pellets were available for the same price as the 20 pound Traeger pellets at the time of publication. The 40-pound Pit Boss bags are the most reasonable of the Pit Boss and Traeger alternatives, costing somewhat less per pound.

Traeger Pellets: How Much Do They Cost?

Only 20-pound packages of Traeger pellets are available. They aren’t the most affordable hardwood pellets on the market. They aren’t the cheapest, but neither are they the most costly.

Traeger pellets are at the same price as Pit Boss 20 pound bags. There’s no way to save money when you buy more because they don’t offer larger ones.

FAQs About Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets

What Are Some of Traeger Grills’ Best-Selling Products?

  • Traeger Lil’ Tex Elite 22 Wood Pellet Grill

The Traeger Lil’ Tex Elite 22 is a pellet grill that offers many of the same features as the other grills in the company’s line-up. It has a digital LED temperature display and an electronic auto-start ignition system for near foolproof operation and comes with a Smart Smoke Technology™ controller that allows you to set and forget your grilling.

This grill also has a built-in meat probe, a 463 square inch cooking surface, a hopper capacity of 18 pounds, and aluminum construction. I think this grill would be best for someone who wants to eventually move on to using charcoal or wood chips for smoking (since it doesn’t come with any) but is still a good choice for an entry-level pellet grill/smoker.

  • Traeger Elite 34 Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker:

The top pellet smoker in Traeger’s line is the Elite 34, and it comes with all of the features you’ve come to expect from this company; Smart Smoke Technology™ controller, digital LED temperature display, auto-start ignition system, etc. But what makes this grill stand out is its ability to cook at low temps (down to 180 degrees F) as well as high temps (up to 500 degrees F), which allows you to do everything from slow cooking a pork shoulder or smoking a brisket up to grilling a steak or even baking pizza at home.

This grill also has a built-in meat probe, an easy-to-clean ash collection system, pellet hopper cleanout (less mess), and a large surface area (463 square inches) for cooking multiple dishes at once. The Elite 34 is truly the top of the line when it comes to this company’s grills; very solid construction and much more heavy duty than their smaller models.

What Are Some of Pit Boss Grills’ Best-Selling Products?

 Pit Boss 71700FB Pellet Grill with Flame Broiler

The Pit Boss 71700FB is an excellent entry-level pellet grill that has some of the features of more expensive models. It comes with 4 burners, 900 square inches of cooking space, and a gas flame broiler for searing steaks at 275 degrees F. The exterior is made from powder-coated steel while the interior is porcelain-enameled in order to create a tougher surface that will be able to handle harsher weather conditions outside without rusting or breaking down prematurely. This grill also has side shelves that are foldable for easy storage when not in use, a front shelf lower warming rack, lid thermometer, and top temperature gauge.

So, Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets, Which Is Better?

We found that Pit Boss and Traeger pellets perform similarly in terms of performance.

They’re both manufactured in the United States from 100% hardwoods with no additives. Both brands appear to have nailed their moisture ratios, resulting in good heat and that wonderful thin blue smoke without a lot of ash to clean up

We’re going to give this one to Pit Boss since they have a wider variety of flavors and offer larger bags, saving you money per pound.

We personally use Traeger pellets on a daily basis and are constantly impressed by their consistency. Pit Boss, on the other hand, has more options at a somewhat lesser price, giving them the advantage in what is a difficult-to-call comparison.

Conclusion Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets

In conclusion, Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets, which one is a better option for your needs. To summarize, both the Traeger and Pit Boss pellets are good options, they include all of the special features?

So, Pit Boss Pellets Vs Traeger Pellets, it depends on what you’re looking for. If you want a smoker that can do it all, then the Traeger is probably your best bet. But if you’re looking for an affordable smoker that still produces great results, Pit Boss is a good option to consider.

Leave a Reply